Skip to Content

The 24 Worst Jukebox Songs (That You Should Never Play)

*This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.


A jukebox is a partially automated music-playing device, usually a coin-operated machine, that will play a patron’s selection from self-contained media. The classic jukebox has buttons, with letters and numbers on them, which, when one of each group is entered after each other, are used to select a specific record. Some may use Compact Discs instead.

Disc changers are similar devices that are intended for home use, are small enough to fit in a shelf, may hold up to 400 discs, and allow discs to be easily removed, replaced, and inserted by the user.

So what are the worst jukebox songs? 

Although everyone will have some jukebox songs they hate there are a few songs though like Shots and American Pie that everyone can agree should not be able to be played on a jukebox at all.

If you would like to know more about the worst jukebox songs, please keep reading or check out this video!

Do you have a game room in your house and you wish that you had a full-sized jukebox to put into it? Well, you are in luck as you can find a variety of them to choose from by clicking here.

Victrola Nostalgic Wood Countertop Jukebox with Built-in Bluetooth Speaker, 50's Retro Vibe, 5 Bright Color-Changing LED Tubes, FM Radio, Wireless Music Streaming, AM/FM Radio, Aux Input

Do you love the thought of a nostalgic jukebox but can’t afford to spend thousands on it?

Then this tabletop jukebox is for you.

Looking and feeling like an old time jukebox but sitting on your counter or table you really can’t go wrong with this one.

Jukebox Songs

All songs on the jukebox should be a specific genre that fits with the establishment, so that when the weekend comes, and you need to have fun, you know where to go. We are going to discuss the worst songs to play in bars and why. 

24 Worst Jukebox Songs 

The bad thing about being a bartender is being at the mercy of your establishment’s jukebox and the patrons who use it to play whatever they want. No one likes horrible songs, that is why people hate other people who play annoying songs!

Here is the list of jukebox songs you probably hate to hear whenever you are out.

1. Shots – LMFAO Ft Lil Jon

This song is as grating as a dump truck driving through a nitroglycerin plant, and it gives people the wrong idea. Overall, it just shouldn’t be on a jukebox. 

2. Red Solo Cup – Toby Keith

This song inspires more spilled drinks than any other. People throw their bottles and drop them everywhere. This not only makes a big mess to clean us, but also gets people mad that they had stuff spilled on them. 

3. Wagon Wheel – Old Crow Medicine Show and Darrius Rucker

The song was good, but it was played so much, now it is annoying every single time it comes on. 

4. Closing Time – Semi Sonic

It was once a loved song, but became warped and twisted by bad customers who think they are funny and played it every night 1 hour before the bar closed. 

5. All Summer Long – Kid Rock

Whenever this song was played, the bartender definitely got tired of hearing it.

The band was good, but your local bar is not where people want to listen to 20 minutes of guitar noodling and peyote references.

6. Most throwback 00s rap songs

At first, the songs were funny but the more they are played, the more everyone hates them being played. 

7. Free Bird – Lynyrd Skynyrd

The more beer you drink, the more likely you are to break down and cry when the song is being played. No bartender  likes that happening.

8. We Are Tired

This song is like it is trying desperately to shove fun down your throat, and it just ends up coming up as puke. The intentions were good, but the song is not. 

9. Don’t Stop Believing- Journey

It is not charming to play this kind of song in a bar under any situation.

10. All I Want To Do – Sheryl Crow

When this song plays at a bar, it gets a bunch of middle-aged ladies up on the dance floor who ask the DJ to play Margaritaville next. If you don’t believe me, go ahead and play this song the next time you are out and see for yourself. 

11. Mr. Brightside – The Killer

The sound of the lead singer bellowing toward the end of the song is reminiscent of the music a cat may make when screeching. Whenever this song is picked on a jukebox,everyone wonders if someone is trying to share a  message about themselves, or if they don’t like someone in the bar. 

12. R.E.M- It’s The End Of The World As We Know It

When this song is played, people think they can sing along, but they end up screwing up the words, so it ends up a bar full of people screaming.

13. Dancing Queen – Abba

This song is much more of a disco song than a normal bar song.

14. Sweet Home Alabama – Lynyrd Skynyrd

If Lynyrd Skynyrd owned a jukebox, this song would not be on it. Once this song was super, but years of non-stop commercialized rocking have made it overused to anyone who listens to music.

15. Smooth- Carlos Santana and Rob Thomas

The song is terrible.Only a few people actually like this song.

16. Hotel California- The Eagles      

The song has been played many times, until it was overplayed.

17. I Will Survive – Gloria Gaynor

This is not a good song, and may bring out inner demons. This is a demonic song and should not be played ever! 

18. Meatloaf – Paradise By The Dashboard Light

The song plays for eight-minutes, then it’s about having sex in a car. 

19. Bawitdaba – Kid Rock

The only time you can select this song is if you are here in the middle of the day. 

20. Piano Man – Billy Joel

This song is extremely sad for those over 37, and makes them cry as they listen to their hopes and dreams that never came true. If you are under 37 you get mad because you have to hear this song one more time!

21. American Pie – Don McLean

The song is nine-minutes long. Many people have said that it has outlived its time and it needs to die.

22. Livin’ On A Prayer – Bon Jovi

Just once again, this song is overused.

23. Sweet Caroline – Neil Diamond

Everyone knows this song, but once a night is definitely the limit.

24. I Have A Feeling – The Black-Eyed Peas

This song although can be good in some settings, is commercialized and overused.

Important Jukebox Etiquette

There are consequences to poor jukebox etiquette. 

Here are 3 key components to keep in mind when you walk up to that magnificent sound machine.

1. Consider the surroundings           

If you are not sure about the crowd, take time to figure the people out or ask the bartender. It is essential to play the right songs for the right group. 

2. Respect the song time

An etiquette minded person will recognize that there are other people that want to play songs as well. Choosing many songs will not make you have many friends as you always take up the jukebox. 

3. Don’t Play The Top 40

The jukebox is no place for the top 40. You should mix the songs up if you are the only one that controls it. 

Don’t Make People Hate Your Jukebox Choice

Whipped cream vodka is the worst thing that happened to the scene over the last decade. The second worst thing is undoubtedly those jukeboxes where you can play virtually anything. Touch Tune jukeboxes and the people who use them to make everyone else miserable.

How can you avoid being a jukebox violator and making people hate you?

  • Don’t play Journey. No person with a sober mind wants to hear that in a bar.
  • Pay attention to where you are. You might not want to go into a hardcore blue-collar Irish bar and toss on Ice T’s Cop Killer.
  • Don’t play the same song more than once per night.
  • Ask the bartender for suggestions if you want to show yourself as a real class act.
  • Stop putting more than $5 in the jukebox.
  • Although touch tunes let you bump other people’s songs in favor of your song selection, this is a total wrong move.
  • Do not hide behind your phone. Some apps let you use a smartphone to control the jukebox of the bar that you are in. People have been seen trying to wreak real havoc this way.
  • Please do not stick your five-dollar bill in the jukebox at 1:55 am and then throw a drunken fit when the bartender turns it off five minutes later.


Now that you know about jukebox etiquette, you can see that it should always be kept in mind. Not everyone will like the same songs of course, but there are definitely ones to avoid.

Now that you have seen which songs to avoid, you will not make the mistake of playing any of the above mentioned songs.